Third Eye Education
  • Read
  • Listen
    • Season 2 | 2022
    • Season 1 | 2021
  • Meet
    • writing team
    • podcasting team
    • origin & founders
  • Collaborate
    • connect with us
    • mission & vision
  • Share

Accessing Mirrors and Seeing Through Windows: Why Students Need Diverse Books

4/9/2021

 
by Heather M. F. Lyke
 — The original version of this piece was first published in December 2018 ​by RPS Secondary Curriculum & Instruction --
My best friends when I was growing up—the ones that I kept going back to again and again for support, reassurance, and comfort—were all fictional. It wasn’t so much that I was a nerd or a bookworm per se (although I did grow up to become both), but rather that my day to day world didn’t have in it anyone who looked or acted like me: so I sought them out in books.
 
You see, as a kid I didn’t have any tangible women in my life with whom I really identified—at least not holistically. My day to day life was filled with men—my father, my older brothers, and most of my friends. And then there was my mom: my mom, who was 100% sugar, and spice, and everything nice—while I, on the other hand, was mainly spice. Unlike my mother, I enjoyed changing the oil with my dad, going fishing with my brothers, and shingling roofs with my guy friends. However, I wasn’t ‘one of the guys’ either: I had a Caboodle full of banana clips and Bonne Bell, Yankee Candle was my favorite store in the mall, and I wore Love’s Baby Soft every day of junior high. So, instead, I found kinship in Mallory from The Baby-Sitter’s Club series, in Jo from Little Women, and in June Osborn [Offred] in The Handmaid’s Tale.
 
The thing is, each of these friends were introduced to me by teachers. I met Mallory at Jefferson Elementary when Mr. Vanort pointed out the series to me one day in the Library. I met Jo at Kellogg when Mrs. Ollenberg noted in the margin of one of my journal entries that I might enjoy it. And, I met June at Mayo when Ms. Evans set her own personal copy on my desk and said I should read it over winter break (I still have that copy, by the way: if you’re reading this Ms. Evans, let me know if you want it back).
Related reading: Mirrors, Windows, and Sliding Doors
But the other thing is: I’m white and cisgender. I was also born in the United States and raised middle class. These factors made it easier for me to see myself in the books I read growing up. It also made it easier for teachers to put the right books in my hands.
 
Unfortunately, for many students, it’s uncommon for them to see themselves reflected in the books they read, and while the diversity we are seeing in children’s and young adult literature is on the rise, it still doesn’t match our student population. 
Picture
Image from Lee and Low
As BJ Epstein, Ph.D., noted in The Conversation, “we know that children’s books can act like both mirrors and windows on the world. Mirrors in that they can reflect on children’s own lives, and windows in that they can give children a chance to learn about someone else’s life.” Knowing this to be true, then as educators it’s important we ensure students have opportunities to see characters who look like them, share similar backgrounds, and have comparable personality traits. Simultaneously, it important to ensure students are reading books that provide insight into worlds different from their own. ​
Related Reading: Time to Bury the Dead White Male

Mirrors

Author Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie, in her 2009 Ted Talk “The Danger of a Single Story,”  sheds light on how her personal view of how she saw herself and who she could aspire to become someday was inaccurate and thin because of the limited types of novels she’d had access to. In other words, the mirror she had access to—the one she was able to hold in her hands—didn’t give her a clear picture of herself.

Windows

Adichie goes on to talk about how the books one reads can also create windows into the lives and worlds different from one’s own. In fact, reading literary fiction helps build empathy.

For me, this was certainly true. My world view expanded greatly through literature. Hurston's Their Eyes Were Watching God helped me begin to comprehend the challenges of being black, poor, and female in America. Cisneros' The House on Mango Street helped me begin to comprehend the challenges of poverty and immigration. Dorris' A Yellow Raft in Blue Water helped me begin to comprehend the challenges of holding on to one's heritage when one is Native American and/or biracial.
Related listening: ​A Fresh Look at Reading with Wiley Blevins
No matter our cultural backgrounds and experiences, reading fiction “can usher us into other worlds—it can make us step into other realities” (Elemans).

Resources

When it comes to surrounding students with literary mirrors and windows, one of the first steps is accessing the right titles and then getting those titles into students’ hands. Below are a wide variety of resources that can help you find texts to then share with students. 
 
Book List Resources:
  • American Indians in Children’s Literature “Best Books” list
  • IRIS Center’s “Children’s Books: Portrayals of People with Disabilities”
  • National Public Radio’s “Book Concierge”
    • When applying the filters ‘Young Adult’ and ‘Identity and Culture’ to the 2020 books, this curated list is created.
    • It defaults to the 2020 list, but one can always go back to explore books published in previous years.
Screenshot of National Public Radio’s “Book Concierge” with the ‘Young Adult’ & ‘Identity and Culture’ filters
Screenshot of National Public Radio’s “Book Concierge” with the ‘Young Adult’ & ‘Identity and Culture’ filters
  • The NCTE (National Council of Teachers of English) Blog, Literacy & NCTE—specifically these posts:
    • “Build your Stack: Our Classroom Libraries Evolve as We Grow and Learn”
    • “Build your Stack: Culturally-Affirming Adult Reads That Will Push Your Classroom Thinking”
    • “Build Your Stack: Widening Our Lens by Bringing Books from around the Globe into K-12 Classrooms”
    • “Diversity in Graphic Novels”
    • “Culturally Sustaining and Inclusive YA Literature: Valuing the Knowledge, Stories, and Truths of Adolescent Life”
    • “Book Recommendations for the African American Read-In” (scroll toward the bottom for YA texts)
  • We Need Diverse Books’ subsite “Where to Find Diverse Books”
    • Also, explore more suggested titles on Twitter: #WNDB
 
Reading Challenges that Honor Diversity in Literature:
  • Rochester Public Library’s “Open Book Challenge”
  • MacMillan Publishers’ “Reading Without Walls” challenge
 
Teacher Supports
  • The Academy of American Poets subsite “Teach This Poem”
    • Educators can also sign up to receive a weekly email including one poem and supporting resources
  • National Education Association’s subsite “Read Across America”
    • Also, explore more suggested titles on Twitter: #ReadAcrossAmerica
 
 
No matter what your role in education, you could be that staff member who hands out mirrors to and opens windows for our students. It’s important that we all work together to guarantee our students are able to see themselves reflected in the books they read and ensure that they’re able to build empathy for those who are different from them.
 
My childhood would have been rough without characters like Mallory, Jo, and June. My worldview would have been much thinner without authors like Hurston, Cisneros, or Dorris. To this day, I am grateful for those teachers who introduced me to these close friends and who showed me more of the world.

These protagonists taught me that being smart and outspoken, being strong-willed and brash was admirable—even if I was a woman. These authors taught me to empathize with others different from myself. Now, imagine what lessons our students will learn if we just introduce each of them to a wider array of books.

Heather M. F. Lyke is the Teaching & Learning Specialist for Dover-Eyota Schools and author of numerous articles focusing on quality education.


Comments are closed.
    Picture
    Picture
    Picture
    ​Third Eye Education posts weekly articles focusing on education and innovation. 

    Archives

    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021

    Categories

    All
    Adaptability
    Autonomy
    Belonging
    Change
    Classroom Culture
    Collaboration
    Communication
    Community
    Creativity
    Cross Curricular
    Discomfort
    Empathy
    Engagement
    Feedback
    Flexibility
    Impact
    Initiative
    Intentionality
    Mindfulness
    Perspective

    RSS Feed

    Tweet to @thirdeyeed
Picture
Articles
Podcast Episodes

​Third Eye Education is supported by Dover-Eyota Public Schools
  • Read
  • Listen
    • Season 2 | 2022
    • Season 1 | 2021
  • Meet
    • writing team
    • podcasting team
    • origin & founders
  • Collaborate
    • connect with us
    • mission & vision
  • Share